Comparisons

Ultrasonic, laser or radar: choosing a distance sensor

DWIN Engineering, , 4 min read

Ultrasonic, laser or radar: choosing a distance sensor

Choose ultrasonic for low cost, short range and targets of any colour or transparency; laser for long range, small targets and fast updates; and mmWave radar for tens of metres, speed measurement and rain, fog or dust.

At a glance

UltrasonicLaser ToFmmWave radar
Typical rangeCentimetres to about 10 mCentimetres to tens of metresTens to hundreds of metres
BeamWide coneNarrow spotShaped by antenna, wide or narrow
Glass and clear liquidsMeasures themLight passes through or scattersPartly transparent
Dark or black targetsNo effectShorter rangeNo effect
Rain, fog, dustMostly worksDegradedWorks
Measures speedNoNoYes, directly
Relative costLowestMediumHighest

When ultrasonic wins

Parking, robot obstacle avoidance, tank and bin levels, and presence detection. A wide beam sees obstacles a narrow beam would miss, and the sensor does not care about colour, transparency or light.

When laser wins

Long range with a small spot, high resolution and fast update rates: positioning, small targets, and places where the beam must not touch nearby walls.

When radar wins

Vehicles moving at speed, outdoor sensing in all weather, and anything where you need the speed of the target as well as its distance, such as blind-spot warning and door-opening protection.

Frequently asked questions

Which is more accurate, ultrasonic or laser?

Laser time-of-flight sensors usually resolve smaller targets and update faster, while ultrasonic sensors are often similar in accuracy at short range. DWIN's R01 laser sensor is specified at 1 cm up to 25 cm and 4% of distance beyond, and its A01 ultrasonic sensor at ±(1 cm + 0.3% of distance). Choose on target type and environment as much as on accuracy.

What is the smallest distance these sensors can measure?

Every sensor has a minimum distance, or blind zone. DWIN's R01 laser sensor starts at 2 cm, the A22 dual-probe ultrasonic sensor at 1 cm, and the 79 GHz door-opening radar at 0.04 m. Sealed single-probe ultrasonic sensors usually have larger blind zones, around 20 to 28 cm.

Which distance sensor works best outdoors?

Radar is least affected by rain, fog, dust and sunlight. Ultrasonic sensors work outdoors in most weather if the transducer is sealed, such as DWIN's IP67 A01-V2.0, but wind and heavy rain can disturb them. Laser sensors lose range in bright sunlight: the R01 is rated 2 to 400 cm indoors but less outdoors.

Ultrasonic distance sensors, Laser distance sensors, Automotive mmWave radar